Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board

Legacy makes clicking noise when driving and rolls in park


Recommended Posts

My 1996 Legacy has been making a clicking noise on the drivers side for the past month when I turn to the right. Today, the noise is more pronounced and is even happening when I drive straight down the street. On top of that, my car is now rolling when I put it into park. I have read lot's of stuff on the net that suggests that this problem could be related to the parking pawl going out or being jammed. I was curious if this issue could be related to the Left CV axle needing to be replaced or if that could have caused the parking pawl to fail? If I replace my drivers side CV axle, could this fix all the issues? Thanks for any help in this matter. DESPERATE

 

Happy New Year,

 

Jake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks so much for the quick replies. If the CV axle was totally broken, would I still be able to drive the car but not be able to put it into park without it rolling on me? I have the e-brake engaged now but I am not going to drive it until I replace the drivers side CV axle. I just wasn't sure if this was common for a car to act in this way. My tranny has been solid and not slipped ever so that is why I'm hoping that these issues I am experiencing are just related to the CV axle failing due to wear and tear.

 

Again, thanks a million!

 

Jake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Putting the trans in park engages the parking pawl to the output shaft of the trans. This only locks the front pinion shaft from turning. The pinion shaft prevents the ring gear on the differential from turning, but it does not prevent the side gears inside the differential from turning.

The axles are connected to the side gears. The side gears will rotate opposite of each other. (This is normal operation for a differential.) If one axle breaks, the axles can then rotate and the car can roll away. (The broken one will rotate the opposite direction of the wheel)

 

The rear wheels are powered by a clutch set in the rear of the trans. The clutch set needs fluid pressure in order to engage. It only gets fluid pressure when the engine is running, and the transmission is in gear. When you start driving the clutch engages and the rear wheels will propel the car. When parked the clutch is free so no power can go to the rear wheels. This also means the rear wheels will not hold the car still when the trans is in park.

 

Put a new axle in it and you'll be set.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow! Thank everyone for your helpful advice and valuable information. I especially LOVE the fact that you took the time Su bah roo'n to give me an education on the components of the front end. This new nugget of knowledge will serve me well now and in the future. I very much appreciate it. I found a re-manufactured drivers side CV axle for $52 from carquest so I'm going to go pick it up. 

 

God bless y'all and have a Happy New Year.

 

Jake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

STOP! Don't do it! Jake come back!

 

OK...2much?   :)

 

Plz don't use that axle, unless you LIKE changing them every 6 months (depending on your # of miles). Those cheap axles don't have a good rep on any of the Subie sites.....pony up for a better one, still less than $100 usually.

 

td

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

hahahaha! You bust me up TD. Thank you for the heads up. I will most definitely shop around then. I do not want to repeat this job in the near future and would rather use quality components to do it right the first time. 

 

Much appreciative,

 

Jake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Sorry everyone, I forgot to update y'all with my CV axle issue. So, I replaced the drivers side CV axle with a brand new one and it now runs like a champ. The old CV axle was completely busted on the wheel side and I was shocked that my car still drove down the road when I heard the initial noises and that it held up so that I could make it home where I chose to park it till I could tear in to it. I want to thank y'all so much for your assistance with this project. I am relieved to have this problem fixed and to be back on the road with my Subie.

 

Hope his thread will help someone else in the future.

 

Jake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 years later...
On 12/29/2014 at 8:03 PM, Fairtax4me said:

Putting the trans in park engages the parking pawl to the output shaft of the trans. This only locks the front pinion shaft from turning. The pinion shaft prevents the ring gear on the differential from turning, but it does not prevent the side gears inside the differential from turning.

The axles are connected to the side gears. The side gears will rotate opposite of each other. (This is normal operation for a differential.) If one axle breaks, the axles can then rotate and the car can roll away. (The broken one will rotate the opposite direction of the wheel)

 

The rear wheels are powered by a clutch set in the rear of the trans. The clutch set needs fluid pressure in order to engage. It only gets fluid pressure when the engine is running, and the transmission is in gear. When you start driving the clutch engages and the rear wheels will propel the car. When parked the clutch is free so no power can go to the rear wheels. This also means the rear wheels will not hold the car still when the trans is in park.

 

Put a new axle in it and you'll be set.

I went to look at a 95 Legacy Wagon today that has the same symptoms. So if it is a broken front cv joint is it ok to drive it six miles? I might be able to get this car at a low price.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Ravenwoods said:

If I buy it I only have to drive about six miles on a lightly traveled road to get it home.

 

It might work, but it's torture for the rear transfer plates.  Might wear them substantially. or might destroy them and leave you unable to drive.  Problem is the TCU tries to disengage the rear more and more the faster you go, so it will be slipping like crazy any speed above 20 mph or so.  I suppose you could cut the wire to the transfer solenoid to go "full lock" mod and splice it back in or install a switch later.

I''d just take an axle, a breaker bar, and a 19mm socket, a 32mm socket and a roll pin punch and change it out before driving.  Only take 30 mins or less to change.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, FerGloyale said:

 

It might work, but it's torture for the rear transfer plates.  Might wear them substantially. or might destroy them and leave you unable to drive.  Problem is the TCU tries to disengage the rear more and more the faster you go, so it will be slipping like crazy any speed above 20 mph or so.  I suppose you could cut the wire to the transfer solenoid to go "full lock" mod and splice it back in or install a switch later.

I''d just take an axle, a breaker bar, and a 19mm socket, a 32mm socket and a roll pin punch and change it out before driving.  Only take 30 mins or less to change.

Thanks for the very helpful advice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...