Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board

2006 Legacy 2.51 Better Head Gasket - Subaru or Six Star


Recommended Posts

what about the other important aspects of this job:

1. resurfacing the heads

2. resurfacing the block

 

Open questions like this are usually limited in scope. The best qualified people don't usually respond. So you'll get anecdotal low grade replies.

 

Ideally you get info from GD, GLoyale, Crawlerdan and people that have replaced significant numbers. Ivansimports as well. But they'd have to quit their jobs to reply to every common question so they don't respond much here.

 

Ideally you do some significant searching and post links or specific questions.

 

It would be nice to curate a thread comprising all of the high capacity folks comments on the subject.

 

I've owned 40 Subarus, worked on many more and have no clue how many headgaskets I've replaced - and still my experience regarding your question is anecdotal and not technically worth a lick. By reading replies you'll just get a bunch of statistically meaningless opinions and experiences like mine.

 

If you search, I know some of those guys have reported before what they use and have seen. It's worth finding what they've said. Use google search and find their usernames from USMB.

 

I'm comfortable using Subaru or Fel Pro based on the comments of really experienced people who have come to their own conclusions.

 

I'm pretty sure crawlerdan has used Fel Pro for years hundreds of times without issues over many years. He's got a statistically significant look at long term success and enormous same size a thread like this will never touch.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Never heard of 6 star.

For these engines. I would go by what GD wrote. I have not had to do one of these newer engines yet. I have done a few older ones, and used Fel pro, which is the only brand I have seen recommended other than oem.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not in the 10's or hundreds of these, but I have done at least a dozen or more of EJ25's, and I agree with Grossgary.

 

I have used both Subaru gaskets and Felpro, and none have come back.

 

Preparation is the key to a successful job. Each time I get the heads resurfaced, and scrub down the mating block surface with a 3M Scotchbrite pad, or 2 or 3 using kerosene as a solvent. I scrub until the block surface is completely clean of any old gasket or  debris.

 

Next is to follow the proper torque sequence and specs for the engine.

 

I have yet to replace head bolts, but you will probably get various answers on this also.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Six Star are just rebranded Cometic gaskets with a premium price. Nothing special about them. We occasionally use Cometics when we need a custom thickness (which is very seldom). No real complaints but honestly the 770 gaskets are as good or better than anything the aftermarket has to offer and they are cheap and readily available at any dealer. Pretty much always in stock. Made by Nippon Rienz. 

 

GD

Edited by GeneralDisorder
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm in the middle of a 2.5L to 2.0L swap and the 2.0L JDM engine uses a 482 (superseded by 483) head gasket.  Main difference from the 770 gasket is the cooling cutouts on the 770 are smaller.  I don't know the significance of that change so decided to use the 11044AA483 from the Subaru Dealer (get cost + 10% as son is employee).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is no significance to the cooling passage alignment. The factory uses gaskets that partially or completely block passages all the time. I have NEVER seen an issue due to gasket/head cooling passage mismatch. If it's for an EJ engine, has the right bore diameter, and the thickness you are looking for then you are OK to run it.

 

GD

Edited by GeneralDisorder
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...
On 5/14/2017 at 7:47 AM, idosubaru said:

what about the other important aspects of this job:

1. resurfacing the heads

2. resurfacing the block

 

Open questions like this are usually limited in scope. The best qualified people don't usually respond. So you'll get anecdotal low grade replies.

 

Ideally you get info from GD, GLoyale, Crawlerdan and people that have replaced significant numbers. Ivansimports as well. But they'd have to quit their jobs to reply to every common question so they don't respond much here.

 

Ideally you do some significant searching and post links or specific questions.

 

It would be nice to curate a thread comprising all of the high capacity folks comments on the subject.

 

I've owned 40 Subarus, worked on many more and have no clue how many headgaskets I've replaced - and still my experience regarding your question is anecdotal and not technically worth a lick. By reading replies you'll just get a bunch of statistically meaningless opinions and experiences like mine.

 

If you search, I know some of those guys have reported before what they use and have seen. It's worth finding what they've said. Use google search and find their usernames from USMB.

 

I'm comfortable using Subaru or Fel Pro based on the comments of really experienced people who have come to their own conclusions.

 

I'm pretty sure crawlerdan has used Fel Pro for years hundreds of times without issues over many years. He's got a statistically significant look at long term success and enormous same size a thread like this will never touch.

ive used literally hundreds of felpro mls. love them. only had two failures. one- im at fault. ill take the blame. second- anti lag, 25 psi, etc- that was not felpros fault.

ive also had great success with cometic- but be cautious of the vendor you purchase from. six states Ive used here and there at customers requests. neither good nor bad opinions of the product

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...
2 hours ago, GeneralDisorder said:

Fail-Pro has never been my choice. Besides I get 642's and 770's for like $29 so why bother? The OEM Subaru turbo gasket has never failed us. 

GD

LOL, GD I should buy them from you at that price! Best I've found is about $78 for the pair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...