Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board

Recommended Posts

I use the 75W-90NS redline gear oil in my '91 Legacy which had a 3rd gear crunch when I bought it 60K miles ago. Gearbox is smooth now; I've either gotten used to avoiding the crunch or the redline is doing it for me.

I need to change the oils in the driveline. Has anyone put in redine oils? I use them in my miata and shifting is a little smoother.

 

Will the dealer put in the oil of my choice even if I have to supply the oil?

 

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I used to trumpet "Castrol TAF-X" also known as "Syntorq" but I have discovered that Valvoline Synpower 75W-90 is just that little bit better, and probably easier/cheaper to get a hold of in the States.

 

Both are far better than Redline. Zero crunching with Valvoline.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

try MT-90. the 75-90 and NS are way to slippery to allow syncros to properly slow down. it's a shame to see this issue come up time after time. once and for all, the MT-90 is the way to go.
As far as I know, 75W-90NS & MT-90 are both "high friction" (non friction modified) 75W-90 lubes. The only difference between them that I can find on the Redline website is the presence of sulfurous high-pressure hypoid additive in the NS. This is good for the diff gears, but corrosive to the synchro metal in the trans ...take yer pick. :D

 

**** ******!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As far as I know, 75W-90NS & MT-90 are both "high friction" (non friction modified) 75W-90 lubes. The only difference between them that I can find on the Redline website is the presence of sulfurous high-pressure hypoid additive in the NS. This is good for the diff gears, but corrosive to the synchro metal in the trans ...take yer pick. :D

 

**** ******!

Isn't NS a 75w90 without sulfurous high-pressure hypoid additive, is it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...the presence of sulfurous high-pressure hypoid additive in the NS. This is good for the diff gears, but corrosive to the synchro metal in the trans...

 

Although I agree that the MT-90 and the NS are both "high-friction," the presence of a sulfur-phosphorous EP additive in gear oil does not automatically mean it's corrosive to the synchros; that's an old wives tale. Sulfur compounds can become reactive under certain circumstances (i.e. sump temperatures above ~250-275 F depending upon the formulation), and sulfur in certain old-style, low-grade base oils will become corrosive quickly. However, most (all?) gear oils sold in the USA & Canada have metal deactivators to address the issue at normal operating temperatures, and therefore are not corrosive. Thus, one need not choose between synchro corrosion and shiftability in a properly formulated, quality lubricant like Redline or those from Specialty Formulations.

 

Also, to each his own, but these Subies specify a GL-5 lube in the mtx, so MT-90 does not meet the spec. I know many guys run a GL-4 or GL-4 mix, but nobody seems willing to confess to running a GL-4 for any considerable mileage to see what happens to the diff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact that mt-90 is a gl-4 doesn't matter a FF to me. i go by what works for the application. i have tried all the common synths in the 5mt and the mt-90 has the lowest gear clash. when you guys stop worrying about the label and use a lube that solves the problem, you will be set free. btw, i used mtl (a lighter grade of mt-90) for 210,000 mi in a 95 corolla transaxle over a 10 year period (even though the label called for a 75w-90) without any dire effect. to each, their own. go out and test everything out there, i know you'll eventually come home to mt-90.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if that combo works for you, i would have to say that you are a brilliant rugged individualist. i used to blend fork oil in a 90 katana 1100. honestly, manually trannys are somewhat finicky, i used mtl in a 90 zr-1 without any ill problems. these sube trannys seem very prone to gear clash and the mt-90 was the only stuff that cleared it up. mobil-1 and the other redline products did NOT solve the problem. tranny has 80k mi on it and i suspect PO did a lot of highway driving. clutch seems to be ok with slight judder only when extremely cold. we just changed out 92 ranger plow truck to mt-90 and it seems to have helped with worn 1-2 syncro. YMMV, of course.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...