Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 88
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

And finally the grooves, repaired.

 

#1. The grooves in the hub teeth. (hub shown removed from the transmission.)

post-16970-136027624805_thumb.jpg

 

#2. Grinding the teeth down to eliminate the groove,

post-16970-136027624811_thumb.jpg

 

#3. The difference between grooves and no grooves.

post-16970-136027624818_thumb.jpg

 

#4. Top profile of hub with grooves removed.

post-16970-136027624822_thumb.jpg

 

#5. Close-up view.

post-16970-136027624829_thumb.jpg

 

Any more definition needed? I still have my camera here and the trans available.

 

Lewis

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Excellent work, thank you!

 

What's the best way to pull that hub/gear/shaft assembly out of the tranny? I assume there are some seals that go with it as well?

 

A small pry-bar or similar will pull the hub from tranny housing. Just be smart as to where you pry, and how much. It usually comes out easy.

 

Post #52, pic #4 shows the shaft of the hub with two seals (white) on the shaft. I have not had an issue requiring these to be replaced, ever. (unless, of course, you mess them up...)

 

Lewis

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the recognition... I'm just trying to help out a bit.

 

BTW, How has it worked out for ya?

 

Lewis.

 

We pulled the extension case on the donor tranny today. Let me refer to the two parts that drive the clutches and receive torque from the clutches as the drive drum (attached to the trans) and the driven drum (inside which the clutch plates are mounted).

 

The transmission is said to have 73K miles on it. It came from a vehicle with wiring harness issues that was not wrecked.

 

The driven drum does indeed have grooves in it from the clutches but not as deep as in the photographs posted by you; especially not toward the rear (aft) of the transmission where they are barely visible.

 

I conclude that some portion of the clutch pack remains interfaced with the teeth (sprockets) of the driven gear even when the vehicle is not in AWD mode. I don't recall the actual distribution of torque to the front and read differentials in that condition but I know there is some torque to the rear all the time.

 

As such, since the grooves are not significant toward the rear I am going to risk putting it in without smoothing out any of the grooves.

 

I MAY RUE THE DAY I DECIDED TO DO THIS.

 

I am as a matter of course, changing the duty solenoid and the attached valve body. I was surprised to see that the one I ordered came with the valve body too so since I already have it I'll install it.

 

At this time I'm waiting for another gasket for the plate beneath the valve body as the plate gasket stuck to the old valve body and without knowing it I removed the gasket on the bottom of the plate by error. Had I known the plate had stuck to the valve body, I could have separated it and saved the bottom gasket.

 

We should have it together next week.

 

I do intend to fix the tranny I've taken out of my car or at minimum the tailshaft assembly.

 

Thanks again for your help. I'll keep y'all posted.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

;) One more thing.

 

FYI

 

I had considered replacing the drive drum to remove the grooves without grinding mine. With the help of good ole Emily at CCR in Denver, I located one with a transmission parts firm reconditioned for $75.00. They guarantee as new condition. (I don't really think your old Em) ;)

 

It seems that they are sold with the transmission output shaft as part of the assembly. I think it's odd that that is the case as the drum clearly mounts on a splined section of the output shaft and one can clearly see an internal retaining ring holding it in place.

 

Subaru prices the part new at ~$175.00 at subaruofdallas.com using the internet discount.

 

I didn't want to take down my tranny and void the "junk yard" warranty even though it isn't long term.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

;) One more thing.

 

FYI

 

I had considered replacing the drive drum to remove the grooves without grinding mine. With the help of good ole Emily at CCR in Denver, I located one with a transmission parts firm reconditioned for $75.00. They guarantee as new condition. (I don't really think your old Em) ;)

 

It seems that they are sold with the transmission output shaft as part of the assembly. I think it's odd that that is the case as the drum clearly mounts on a splined section of the output shaft and one can clearly see an internal retaining ring holding it in place.

 

Subaru prices the part new at ~$175.00 at subaruofdallas.com using the internet discount.

 

I didn't want to take down my tranny and void the "junk yard" warranty even though it isn't long term.

 

Steve

 

Well scratch that. The transmission supply house can't provide what I need. They do have the output shaft with the clutch (driven) drum but can't get the shaft with the driving drum.

 

FYI the Subaru part number for the shaft and driving gear is 31458AA001 and is listed as Shaft Assy. Reduction Drive. This part is available for less than $200.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Replacement tranny in. I changed the duty solenoid for good measure and everything is working great. $466 for the tranny with 70K miles on it; about $150 for a new duty solenoid and other misc. parts; and $350 to R&R the tranny (I'm too old to do that stuff lying on my back). Less than $1,000 to refurb the car with a much newer 70K vs. 211K trans. Not bad I'd guess.

 

Apparently I was right in assuming that some wear on the drums was acceptable as there is no torque bind.

 

Now I will do the torque bind fix on the working tranny I removed from the car and will offer it for sale or look for a car needing that trans and perhaps get a good deal together.

 

Thanks again all.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 10 months later...
We're experiencing torque bind in our 96 Legacy Outback. 200K miles plus on this car. No question that torque bind is the problem.

 

I've put the appropriate fuse in the FWD fuse holder and am puzzled by the outcome. SOMETIMES the FWD light on the dash will illuminate and the rear drive-train disengages...but sometimes not. Sometimes when starting the day and the vehicle is cool the FWD illuminates as described but after a drive of 10-15 miles it goes out and the rear again locks up. Sometimes it doesn't disengage at all when initially started and stays that way through the day.

 

The intermittent nature of this makes me wonder if the transmission controller isn't malfunctioning as well as the duty solenoid C.

 

 

Does anyone have any experience with this intermittent symptom?

 

I'm not meaning to be rude in any way but PLEASE, I don't need speculation I need verified experience. This isn't the time for opinions. I'm really frustrated by this problem.

 

Steve

 

 

i similarly have this problem. cept in my case i have never seen the fwd light come on on the dash.. where is it? and does that mean my solenoid C is done as well? or is there another possible reason...?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i similarly have this problem. cept in my case i have never seen the fwd light come on on the dash.. where is it? and does that mean my solenoid C is done as well? or is there another possible reason...?

 

Means the bulb may be burned out of broken. The FWD light will be under the tach. It is on when the FWD fuse is inserted.

 

 

nipper

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i similarly have this problem. cept in my case i have never seen the fwd light come on on the dash.. where is it? and does that mean my solenoid C is done as well? or is there another possible reason...?

 

Aside from the FWD light on and off, I would consider this to be the worst case scenario. Replace the tail housing, grind the afore mentioned teeth, and replace solenoid "C", and the two seals on the rear output shaft that transmit hydraulic power to the clutches, they are white-ish in color, square-cut, and placed in grooves that are on the shaft of the hub.

 

Lewis

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...

Great thread. Thanks for all the info here. My 96 impreza OBS will be happy I found this thread! I'll be diving into the repairs within the next few weeks.

 

My only question is where is the best place to buy the parts? The selonoid, the gaskets and whatever else I'll need to fix this torque bind.

 

I'd like to buy the parts from someone who knows exactly what parts I'll need when I tell them I'm replacing the duty C selonoid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great thread. Thanks for all the info here. My 96 impreza OBS will be happy I found this thread! I'll be diving into the repairs within the next few weeks.

 

My only question is where is the best place to buy the parts? The selonoid, the gaskets and whatever else I'll need to fix this torque bind.

 

I'd like to buy the parts from someone who knows exactly what parts I'll need when I tell them I'm replacing the duty C selonoid.

 

call an online dealer and they will know exaclty what your talking about.

 

https://www.subarugenuineparts.com/oe_parts_cat.html

www.1stsubaru.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

tcu-diagnosis-connector-96-1.giftcu-diagnosis-connector-96-2.gif

 

I printed the above pic and took it out to my car. I finally found the black 6 post connector. It wasn't connected to anything. I assume it is not supposed to be? There are only 3 wires going into the connector. a wire goes in the #1 and 2 positions on the top outside corners and then the 3rd wire (green with yellow stripe) goes in the #5 position. In the pic above it shows many more wires than just 3 going into the connector. :confused: The black connector on my car is quite a bit smaller and more square than what the above pic shows but It did have the 2 ground wires taped to it though. I assume I have the correct connector? :confused:

 

 

 

I first stuck one ground wire pin into #5 hole and my AT temp light did nothing other than what it's always done (16 flashes on start up). I tried it with the key on, off and with the car running. Then, I tried the 2nd ground and still nothing. Then I tried both grounds jammed into the #5 terminal and nothing.

 

The only thing my AT temp light does is flash 16 times and then stops. I cannot get it to give me the long and short flashes so I can figure out what code it is putting out.

 

Am I doing something wrong here?

Edited by Bigbusa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm, That would make sense. My car is a 96. Since this black connector has the 2 ground wires with the long pins on the ends taped to it... it still must be the connector I would use to check the AT temp codes right?

 

I must have to stick one of the ground pins in the #1 or the #2 holes then? I've already ruled out the #5 hole. :-\

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hm yah not sure; sometimes the diagnosis connector does a variety of things when various pins are gounded. I have the '96 (Legacy) service manual that maybe I can check out in a bit.....have to take out the garbage and feed the kittehs and wash some towels first though. :grin:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks porc.

 

Just for kicks I grounded holes #1 and #2.

 

#1 made the airbag light flash.

 

#2 and #5 do nothing.

 

I'm kinda lost here. I have the AT temp light flashing 16 times ...indicating a problem, but I don't know how to extract the code. :-\

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:looking around: Ok big b but if anyone asks it's your fault the kittehs, laundry, and garbage have to wait hahahehhah

 

Indication of Failure

 

When any on-board diagnostic item is malfunctioning, the display on the AT OIL TEMP indicator blinks immediately after the engine starts. The malfunctioning part or unit can be determined by a trouble code during on-board diagnostic operation. Problems which occurred previously can also be identified through the memory function. If the AT OIL TEMP indicator does not show a problem (although a problem is occurring), the problem can be determined by checking the performance characteristics of each sensor using the select monitor. Indicator signal is as shown in the figure.

 

 

 

WARNING: Warning can be noticed only when the engine is initially started.

 

 

 

 

hm..not sure Big b, says "Transmission flash codes are obtained by grounding terminal # 5 of Diagnosis Connector B82, a 6 pole black connector located on right side of steering column, with one of the leads (either one) from the Diagnosis Terminal. "

 

And the diagrams look just like above.

 

http://www.endwrench.com and search 4eat, that have some articles on there, might descirbe 4eat phase I codes better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hmmm, I guess I can't diagnose it through that method. :confused: Thanks though!

 

If anyone else has any ideas I'd be interested.

 

I'll take some pics of the connector tomorrow. I'm pretty sure I have the right one because it has the 2 ground wires taped to it and it's a 6 pole connector. :-\

Edited by Bigbusa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh no. No dealers for me. I've learned my lesson too many times. If you want something done right (and inexpensively), do it yourself.

 

I think I read on the other thread that you had a dealer fix your TB issues for $1000? I can't dump that kind of money on a 13 year old 184k mile car. Especially when I need to buy 4 new strut shocks (close to $400) and install them myself in the near future.

 

Maybe I can't check the codes but from what I've read here, the torque bind symptoms all point to the duty C selonoid. I'll head in that direction.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...