Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board
BratRod

Vacuum advance Cross Ref. question

Recommended Posts

http://www.ebay.com/itm/SMP-STANDARD-VC-292-Vacuum-Advance-/200855122568?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&hash=item2ec3e5f288&vxp=mtr

 

http://www.oreillyauto.com/site/c/detail/BWD0/V592/02818.oap?year=1982&make=Honda&model=Civic&vi=1167869&******=Search_vacuum+advance_1167869_530&keyword=vacuum+advance

 

Ovbiously looks can be decieving. I also have no intention of buying rom ebay, BUT... these do look considerably close to the timing advance on my 85 EA81 Brat with hitachi disty. Other than bolting up and looking like its doing its job correctly, should I be concerned with things like the throw? or the rating on the diaphragm or??? I plan on going up to oreillys and sizing them up, but are there things i should be cautioned of before attempting something like this. What do you guys think?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

theres a half dozen different styles of vacuum advances, and there are hundreds more that are different tweeks of the same style.

 

yes the arm length matters, as well as the speed they advance. you would just have to send it in to be recalibrated to work, which is the same as sending in your old one to have it rebuilt.

 

subarus have a super high amount of vaccuum advance over other motors that I can think of. the ones I have go up 25 degrees or so, while a standard "350" advace is 10-15 deg. I wouldnt try random ones for multiple reasons, but even if it "fit" its unlikely to give you the right amount of advance.

 

I know theres a place in portland that rebuilds them for 25ish bucks. probably someone in any major city somewhere that will do the same. you can also rebuild it yourself, it mainly just takes patience to make sure it doesnt leak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
http://www.ebay.com/itm/SMP-STANDARD-VC-292-Vacuum-Advance-/200855122568?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&hash=item2ec3e5f288&vxp=mtr

 

http://www.oreillyauto.com/site/c/detail/BWD0/V592/02818.oap?year=1982&make=Honda&model=Civic&vi=1167869&******=Search_vacuum+advance_1167869_530&keyword=vacuum+advance

 

Ovbiously looks can be decieving. I also have no intention of buying rom ebay, BUT... these do look considerably close to the timing advance on my 85 EA81 Brat with hitachi disty. Other than bolting up and looking like its doing its job correctly, should I be concerned with things like the throw? or the rating on the diaphragm or??? I plan on going up to oreillys and sizing them up, but are there things i should be cautioned of before attempting something like this. What do you guys think?

 

Other than fit,you need to be concerned with how much total advance it has.

Also how much vacuum it takes to start the advance and how much vacuum it takes for full advance.

 

Subaru used 3 or 4 different vac advances on ea-81s w/hitachis.

Looking at a 84 FSM shows that the differences are very minor.I would be surprised if you noticed a difference.

 

I have a good one from an 83 you could have cheap.

Unfortunately,it has no #s for a positive ID.

 

Upon examination,it appears total advance is controlled by the sleeve under the spring.Advance rate is controlled by the spring.Looks to be a trivial matter to swap the spring and sleeve from one Hitachi vacuum advance to another similar one.(compress the spring and slide the retainer off the shaft)

I would get another similar looking Hitachi vac advance(new like in your links or used) and swap your existing spring and sleeve onto it and call it done.

 

Another option is a used one from http://car-part.com/ .

84s should be the same as your 85.Compare dizzy numbers.

I bought a complete ea-82 turbo dizzy in order to get an ea-81 turbo vac advance.Spare ignition module was a bonus.

Complete dizzy is probably only a few more bucks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
theres a half dozen different styles of vacuum advances, and there are hundreds more that are different tweeks of the same style.

 

yes the arm length matters, as well as the speed they advance. you would just have to send it in to be recalibrated to work, which is the same as sending in your old one to have it rebuilt.

 

subarus have a super high amount of vaccuum advance over other motors that I can think of. the ones I have go up 25 degrees or so, while a standard "350" advace is 10-15 deg. I wouldnt try random ones for multiple reasons, but even if it "fit" its unlikely to give you the right amount of advance.

 

I know theres a place in portland that rebuilds them for 25ish bucks. probably someone in any major city somewhere that will do the same. you can also rebuild it yourself, it mainly just takes patience to make sure it doesnt leak.

 

25 degrees? Really? what year is that?

84s have 12 degrees.

 

Have you rebuilt one yourself?

Where did you get the diaphragm?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

87 carbed ea82.

 

I have tried 2.

 

first was already on the car, but was leaking. car did fine but I found one that didn't leak at the JY, so I replaced it (another carbed ea82, same dist). checked again and it was the same.

 

I must admit though, the car hasn't run right since I replaced the leaky one, I've thought about putting the damn thing back on. I know its just a tuning thing, but it just refuses to dial in right.

 

I have other problems too, but both cans showed 25 degrees increase when hooked to manifold vac. might be the dist itself, I haven't dug into it yet.

 

either way I still say get the one you have rebuilt, the settings are all over the place for different cars, and you will spend less that way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since similar looking hitachi vacuum advances have diaphragms with identical surface areas,the settings are completely determined by the spring and sleeve which are VERY easily swapped to a unruptured junkyard unit.

 

You will spend less that way.

 

12 and 25 degrees sounds suspiciously like the difference between distributor and crankshaft degrees.Too early in the morning to be sure of that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

for mine its actual vacuum advance.

 

I hooked up the vac line to manifold to bring it to full advance, dialed in the distributor to 22 deg just so it was on a mark somewhere. pulled the line and checked again and it was at -2ish. plug the vac line back in and back up to 25.

 

normally its hooked to ported of course, but I wanted to see how much it had.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just one furthur thought....

 

Preload on the spring controls when the advance starts so the installed length of the spring needs to stay the same.I`m guessing the diaphragms have arms of the same length,but,you should check.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A very late update:

 

The timing advance i purchased from O'reillys was from a 1982 civic (The one in the link on the first page) Everything checked out, so i brought it home and swapped the sleeve and spring from the old advance. Once bolted up to the Brat it started up, as usual. Upon depressing the accelerator, there seemed to be a sweet spot at which the engine would rev, and only to about 5K. When you would floor it: bogging and backfire. This was due to the arm being longer on the new advance. So, I redrilled the advance tabs to compensate for the difference in length, and volla! Perfect running rubber-burnin' Brat once more. :banana:

 

It has been two weeks since the new advance has been on and i have yet to experience an issue. Very happy with the results, no missing at all now.

 

Thanks to everyone who helped out on this issue :drunk:

 

T.J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So I'm trying to fix the Vac advance on my EA81 Turbo (from the factory, not retrofit.)

 

I got a 82 honda civic advance diaphram from Autozone.  Part number JV1421 from Duralast.

I don't like house brands like duralast but Autozone could get it the quickest and it will be easy to return.

 

The honda vacuum unit is very different from the Subaru unit.

 

Biggest issue is it is 0.25 inches shorter.  

 

My measurement is from center of the mounting hole to center of the mounting hole.

 

Stock unit:  1.726 inches

post-54979-0-46388700-1460990833_thumb.png

 

Duralast JV1421:  1.455 Inches

post-54979-0-36094500-1460991023_thumb.png

 

Also the Duralast unit does not have a threaded mounting hole like the Subaru unit.  

The Mounting hole in the distributor would have to be drilled and tapped.

 

This part looks exactly like the unit linked Ebay and Oriley previously in the thread.

 

This thread references a honda Vacuum Advance, but for an 82 HONDA ACCORD

http://www.ultimatesubaru.org/forum/topic/47195-wanted-hitachi-vacuum-advance-units/

 

Standard Motor part # VC-429

According to Rock auto Parts matching is not the same accord to civic.

 

Next step is to compare one of these.

 

It could just be that the Turbo unit is very different than the naturally aspirated dizzy.

Edited by coronan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is entirely different.

 

I told you that on your other post.

 

That's why I bought a whole new turbo distributor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Currently Philbin has had my Advance diaphram for 3 weeks and just told me today they need more time?   :banghead:  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×