Hello
I have a feeling the dealership is taking me for a ride
I'm not a mechanic and am lacking knowledge and technical terms, but I believe the problem is well described below.
My 1995 Legacy LS wagon (253,000 km) began inconsistently misfiring a few months back. At first it was only on the highway so I didn't feel the car jerk but did see the check engine light flash. My mechanic couldn't pinpoint he cause so had me continue to drive, asking me to bring her back if the problem got any worse. Over a few months, she began to misfire somewhat more consistently and now at city street speeds (at this speed I could feel the car jerk), so I brought her back to my mechanic who still couldn't pinpoint the cause and so sent me to the dealership. After a 1600$ repair bill where they worked on this and an issue I had where she was sluggish for 5-10 min of driving from a cold start, the dealership informed me that the Crank Pulley is bent, dowel pin for crank is worn and crankshaft is getting worn due to the dowel pin. While the sluggish behaviour from a cold start seems resolved, she's still misfiring. At this point it's back to being less consistent, most of the time at highway speeds but occasionally at street speeds. I brought her back to the dealership and they promptly told me that it's because of the bent crank. They went on to say that this was a diagnosis they could only make once they were working on car and disassembled the components to some level. With the engine running I can see a slight wobble in the lower wheel that the timing belt passes around (sorry for the non technical terms).
The misfire codes Subaru recorded were P0304 & P0303. same error codes persist after the work they performed.
Is the bent crank somethign that should have advised me to before any work was done or are they now trying to cover their asses from an oversight on their part?