Jump to content
Ultimate Subaru Message Board

Ginger48

Members
  • Posts

    61
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Ginger48

  1. How do you figure this? The bypass valves are set at a specific pressure. The size of the filter isn't going to change the amount of pressure the pump puts out to any great degree - it shouldn't if designed properly and the engine is operated within it's allowable ambient temp range.

     

    GD

     

    It's very simple. The less filtering media there is (and Subaru oem oil filters ARE small) and the more contaminants there are in the filter WHEN the oil is cold and thick, the oil IS going to find the least restrictive place to flow through.....and that's the bypass valve. Why do you think oil filter manufacturers install bypass valves in their filters? If they didn't, you'd blow a hole in the filter media. When the bypass valve opens, guess where all the contaminants that were previously trapped in the filter goes? The oil filter manufacturers aren't going to install something that isn't necessary and doesn't ever get used.

     

    Conversely, the larger the filter (more filter media) the less restrictive it is and less likely the bypass valve will need to open when the oil is cold and thick.

     

    If you use synthetic oil, or you change your oil and filter every 3,000 miles this is most likely a moot point.

     

    EDIT:

    Oil filter bypass valves are NOT designed to open at a specific oil pressure. They are designed to open at a specific pressure differential. The more contaminants there are in the filter and or the colder the oil is, the greater the pressure differential.

  2. Bottom line... a larger filter does not mean better filtration. What a larger filter will allow is a slight increase in capacity. Nothing more.

     

    Sorry, but you did miss one important benefit of using a larger filter. When starting a cold engine, the bypass valve can open thus allowing dirt previously caught in the filter to circulate through the engine. The thicker the oil, the colder it is, and the smaller the filter, the greater the chances this will happen. In cold climates it's best to use the largest filter available.

  3. If you want the ultimate in oil filters install a Frantz bypass oil filter. It will keep your oil analytically clean 100% of the time. Some will bad mouth the Frantz but modern oil analysis tests have proven the Frantz does work as advertised.

     

    Any full flow filter, regardless of manufacturer, is nothing more than a screen that removes the large particles. A bypass filter on the other hand removes much smaller particles. Large over the road diesels that run for over 1 million miles use both full flow and bypass oil filters.

  4. 1986GL 311,000 miles on the clock and still counting. Still original engine that's never been opened up. Uses one quart of oil/1800 miles. I don't change the oil....just the Frantz oil filter cartridge. Body still good. Purchased when it was 3 years old.

     

    1986GL 163,000 miles. Unknown past.

  5. For the last 21 years I've always used aftermarket 160 or 180 degree thermostats in all my EA82's and NEVER had any cooling issues. Using 195 degree thermostats will slightly increase fuel mileage but they also put increased strain on the cooling system due to the increased pressure the extra heat creates. Since I also own Chevrolets and the thermostats are interchangeable with Subaru, I usually use Chevrolet thermostats. If a Chevrolet thermostat will flow enough to cool a 454 cubic inch engine, I'll flow enough to cool a little 1800 cc (110 cubic inches) engine.

     

    Remove your thermostat, place it in a pan of boiling water on the stove. If it fully opens, it's not the thermostat.

  6. I'm sure how fast gasoline deteriorates depends on the climate. My 87 Subaru sat unused for 3 years in the garage with 1/2 tank of fuel in a cool very dry climate. It started right up 2 months ago as if it had fresh gas in it. My old 1945 Jeep has sat with the same gas in it for up to 8 years at a time and never experienced any problems. I believe heat and moisture are the killers.

  7. The many distillation plants that are being built in the midwest that are pumping massive amounts of water out of the Ogallala aquifer to make E85 is only adding to the future food shortage problem. There is only so much water available and when it’s gone.....I don’t want to think about it.

  8. Additional information: we live at 9000 ft above sea level and frequently drive up to and through the Eisenhower Tunnel on Interstate 70 which is over 11,000 ft above sea level. We even occasionally drive up Mt. Evans and Pikes Peak which are both over 14,000 ft. High elevations = very thin air = extreme stress on a cooling system. I have never experienced a cooling system problem with any of my Subarus by using aftermarket thermostats. Anyone blaming aftermarket thermostats for their problems should check their radiators for restricted air flow or scale inside the radiator.

     

    Sorry, you can compare thermostats side by side all you want but that doesn't tell you anything about how they work in real life.

  9. Iron V8s don't need the T-stat to open and close as quickly to regulate temperature. Plus anything with a 454 has a ginormous radiator and alot of coolant capacity. Their cooling system is actually not working as hard as ours.

     

    Remeber that the thermostats real job is not cooling, it's REGULATION of the temperature. Those aftermarket T-stats open pretty quick and stay open pretty much completely once warm. Read all the posts about EA82 *overcooling*.

     

    At the same time they(aftermarkets) have a smaller flow (smaller opening) which means at peak demand it can't flow enough, even though it's fully open. This means you're car can go from running too cool down a hill, then overheating going up it.

     

    OEM T-stat will stay closed a bit longer, allowing for faster warm-up. They also react more quickly at their set temperature, actually restricting flow if the engine starts getting too cool like it's supposed to.

     

    It really is a part that there IS a difference on.

     

    :confused: ?????????

     

    Chevrolet had an aluminum engine option. Granted, there wern't alot of em built BUT they used the same cooling system parts as the cast iron engines.

     

    Subarus can't flow as much coolant as Chevrolet. Subaru radiator hoses are smaller, and the radiator coolant passages and the physical dimensions of the radiator are much smaller. Take the tanks off a Subaru radiator and you will see how small the tubes are.

     

    I personally have not used anything BUT Chevrolet thermostats for the last 18 years in my Subarus and have NEVER had any problems of any kind with them.

  10. "This applies to thermostat's as well - the OEM part cost's about $2 - $4 more than the aftermarket, and the construction quality is pretty obviously better. A long time ago I posted pictures comparing the differences to illustrate this point...."

     

    Incidentally - the aftermarket thermostats have a much lower maximum flow velocity compared to OEM parts, so you risk overheating if you drive in a hilly environment (I live in VT and see the issue all the time) I've had two friends burn their engines up by replacing a worn thermostat with an aftermarket one.

     

    The aftermarket Subaru thermostat is a Chevrolet V8 thermostat that was used on all v8's up through the 454 cu in. Are you saying a Subaru is more difficult to cool than a 454?

×
×
  • Create New...