Just an update. I was able to grab a starter of an 05 LGT 5MT for $50 shipped. It just arrived Friday, but I haven't had the chance to look at the model or anything like that. I plan to pull it apart, clean it, grease it (if needed) and just do a straight swap. Since I couldn't find the parts and I don't have a garage I figured it would be easier to just swap than to pull, try and source parts come back and install again.