I have a 2001 forester with 90,000 miles and the transmission is starting to make some noise, kind like a bearing is starting to go. My dealer recommens replacing the unit for $3000.00 plus. Is there a common problem with these units that can be repaired or is a replacement the way to go.

replacement is a fine way to go if you're sure it's the trans. more details would help, trying to diagnose over the internet is hard enough without any details on a particular problem. 90,000 is not a normal interval to be having any trans problems. give as many details as possible - describe the noise, when it happens, how it started, all the time/some of the time, comes and goes, only during certain times, temperatures, at start up...etc. you get the point, describe it as best as possible what it sounds like and how it started.

 

is it AWD? if so - all the tires should match in tread depth and the tire pressures should be close to the recommended values. if not the TCU won't function properly.

 

have the fluid flushed in the trans. this can improve drivability. you change your engine oil what every 3,000 or 5,000 miles and some people go 100,000 miles or more and never change the trans fluid. it's not subjected to as much abuse but it also does alot - it's a hydraulic fluid, a coolant and a lubricant for your trans and can degrade. replacing the trans filter is a good idea, but not necessary.

 

check with a transmission specialty shop, i know a guy having a soob trans rebuilt right now was quoted 1,500 - 2,000 and that was with some performance mods included. also - if they look at it they may find it's not something so drastic.

 

another option - i'd look for a used unit. i've had a used trans in my XT6 for about 70,000 miles with no issues and see no reason to not expect lots more miles out of it. a local trans shop said they would install a trans for me (when i seperated my shoulder) for 150 - 200. i ended up doing it myself, but my point is that i'd rather install a used trans for 1,000 than spend 3000 on a new or rebuilt unit.

 

whatever option you choose, have an aftermarket transmission cooler installed. they cost 29.00.