I am trying to decide between a 2005 Outback vs. WRX. (I am not considering the STI.) I test drove both, expecting to fall in love with the WRX, but really preferred driving the Outback. That said, I was looking forward to getting something different, as my current car is an Outback. I wonder if my preference of the Outback is simply that it's familiar.
Being in the mountains of Northern AZ, I do need something that will handle winter driving conditions with ease, so there's no question but that a Subaru is my choice, I'm just not sure which one!
Also, being in AZ I will get a light exterior color, but I'm not crazy about the interior I would then get w/an Outback. The interior of the WRX is more appealing to me. I'm likely going to drive both cars again today, and see if I feel any differently.
I also hesitate to take on the added care the WRX will require in premium fuel, more frequent oil changes, etc.. So, maybe I've already decided! However, if anyone wants to throw in their opinion, I'd be glad to read it.