My top concerns are reliability, and low maintenance. By low maintenance I mean something closer to being a facet of reliability. I want it to not be prone to frequent expensive repairs. I am accustom to putting a descent and consistent amount of money into monthly or bimonthly maintenance and upkeep, that's fine! I've grown up driving only Jeep Cherokees and Wranglers that, while still requiring all the routine maintenance, can handle the cold and occasional things I violently run over. I'm not expecting a Subaru to be able to handle light rock climbing and mudding like my 08 Rubicon, but I want it to not be phased by daily driving year round, significant puddles, and "two track" roads in Michigan's Upper Peninsula that are only groomed in the summer. I need to get through some respectably sandy and muddy trails for camping and visiting my Aunt's cabin. I'm confident that the powertain in the Subaru's mentioned above will be plenty sufficient. With that accounted for, my main concern is:
Reliability
Durability (Resistance to significant breaks)
Longevity (6 years would be excellent)
Versatility (Snow driving + sleeping space)
Things like initial cost to acquire and cost of monthly upkeep should be more negligible for me. Gas mileage is not as important either but I would like something that gets 20+ MPG highway. I don't care if it's fast or handles agilely. I want a practical car for a practical MMMAN!