So I've decided the delayed cranking of the starter on my '98 Legacy GT is the start/ solenoid itself, so I want to replace it. I like using Rock Auto, I can get a remanufactured Denso for $108 vs. a new Bosch for $107 (in either case I'll keep the old one and maybe change out the copper contacts in my spare to to see if that fixes it and keep it as a spare for one of our 2 Legacies).

 

I know many lean toward Denso because it's OEM, but in my experiences (from many years ago, the last time I had to replace a starter) that new are generally better than rebuilt, so I'm on the fence.

 

So new Bosch or remaunfactured Denso?

Denso remanufctured starters are very high quality. I've replaced several of those in the last couple years and I dont hesitate to use them or recommend them. If I can get a Denso, I'll pay more for it. Saving $40-50 isn't worth the hassle of having to swap a starter again. Especially on the Toyota V8s with it down in the valley under the intake manifold.

 

The Bosch starters are good as well but normally they cost quite a bit more. Kind of a toss-up either way, in this case, I think you'll get a good quality part.

1/10th that price for contacts from ebay. Our local Subaru dealer sells them (not subaru part numbers). Toyota sells them for their cars. Super easy cheap fix. Buying a starter is wasteful.

 

GD