Subaru over here will tell you it has been overtightened if it is cracked around the rolled steel inserts, (even if it is only a few thousands kms/miles old!!) I am a HUGE fan of the alloy cover. Over here they didn't go plastic till about 99 on Turbo cases, but on N/A's they were plastic in the 'cheaper' 97 'updates'.
Also, while you are there, remove the piston pin bungs, (large, (14mm?), cap screw on lh side of bell housing behind flywheel., (there is one behind the breather plate also, but it doesn't matter if that one leaks. THese 'bungs' use an alloy washer and hardening type Permatex Sealant, (no 4?). Remove the bung and buff the dried sealant off it. Clean the surfcace of where the washer meets the case, making sure not put any crap down the bore?? Put some non hardening sealant, like Permatex Aviation Gasket -No 3), or even threebond works well!
Cheers
sixpack