Hi,
Have you thought of getting it onto a 4 gas emission analyser - if possible get two readings, one when cold and one when it's warmed up, I think you may be concentrating too much on the "too rich" idea, just because cylinders 1,2 & 4 plugs are black doesn't always mean that it's too rich - it could be that they are not firing efficiently enough so that they soot up - after all number 3 is ok !.
If possible please post 4 gas readings here !.
Regards
Dave H.