Yep, all compressions were equal (or at least reasonably so). The valve looks fine from the face. I'll get them out of the head on Monday and see from there. So far, the shims on the 2 and 4 bank of cylinders seem to be pretty close to the same size, not a whole lot of variance. This is the first time this engine has been opened up so the shims are original.
The misfire symptoms have been traced through spark(plugs, wire, coil pack, knock sensor) fuel( injectors) and air (MAF sensor, compression). It seems the tight valve is the most likely culprit. The head gasket didn't look to bad, but the new one will give me peace of mind.