Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Ultimate Subaru Message Board

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Severe Shaking, Shuddering

Featured Replies

I just replaced the clutch, transmission and lower ball joints in my 90/91/94

Legacy, and it shudders and shakes when I release the clutch, but only

sometimes.

If I burn the clutch, it doesn't shake and accelerates smoothly, but if I release the clutch normally, the whole drivetrain moves a significant distance as it

shakes, and the car's motion is jerky.

I have double, even triple checked my bolts, and they all are tight and everything is attached properly.

 

Grrrr, is this normal or what?

 

Twitch

 

PS: Is it normal for the shifter to be able to touch the driveline when shifting?

It sounds like either a warped flywheel, damaged friction plate, damaged pressure plate or contamination on the friction plate... it's something in the clutch. There is a small chance that the gearbox and engine aren't aligned but this is much more rare.

Are all the clutch parts new? did you at least get the flywheel resurfaced if not new? Is the clutch adjusted properly? Did you get any liquids or grease or anything on the clutch disc?

  • Author
Are all the clutch parts new? did you at least get the flywheel resurfaced if not new? Is the clutch adjusted properly? Did you get any liquids or grease or anything on the clutch disc?

 

Flywheel was professionally resurfaced and all other clutch parts are

brand spanking borgpwarner new.

And no contamination, practically did a white glove service.

Also, my pilot bearing whines.

 

Twitch

  • Author

New symptom!

It shakes and there is an audible rattle or repetitive thudding when I start it.

Just like when I'm starting off.

And since the clutch has been used a bit more the shuddering has been reduced

so I'm guessing it was just because it was a new clutch, but this new symptom

is making me think I need to replace my engine mounts.

But when I had it apart they seemed just fine....

Any other suggestions?

 

Twitch

 

PS: I did a search and came up with nothing.

Your going to have to take it apart again.

 

 

nipper

  • Author
You sure the flywheel bolts were tight?

 

Yes, all bolts were tightened to spec and a little over.

 

Your going to have to take it apart again.

 

 

nipper

 

And please explain before I do.

I can't afford to tear this thing down again.

 

Twitch

If it wasnt doing it before, and it is doing it after, then you have to dig back into it. There is not a hell of a lot of things to go wrong with a clutch that can be repaired externally. It sounds like it can be too thin a flywheel, a bad pressureplate, a broken spring etc. The only other thing it is worth checking is the clutch fork, make sure it is still mounted and in one piece. But the fact that that the noise is getting worse may not give you any choice but to dig into it.

 

nipper

  • Author
If it wasnt doing it before, and it is doing it after, then you have to dig back into it. There is not a hell of a lot of things to go wrong with a clutch that can be repaired externally. It sounds like it can be too thin a flywheel, a bad pressureplate, a broken spring etc. The only other thing it is worth checking is the clutch fork, make sure it is still mounted and in one piece. But the fact that that the noise is getting worse may not give you any choice but to dig into it.

 

nipper

 

Problem is, this car was originally an auto... :rolleyes:

So anything that crops up now may be severe, or nothing and something I just

have to get used to.

Like that %#@$*&^!@% squealing pilot bearing.

But I did have to make a new spring clip, as I either lost one, or it never came

with the donor car.

It was made out of spring metal that had about the same properties as the clip.

But, the shuddering is happening when starting as well, so could that be

motor mounts? Tranny mounts?

 

Twitch

Ah minor details that are left out.

 

What year is this car?

  • Author

Sorry nip.

Its a 90 body, 91 engine, and a 94 tranny.

Lets just say this thing has a Carfax rap sheet that'll make a convict look away

with shame.

I installed the spec clutch for a 90-94 lego, after I verified parts #'s, checking

to make sure they didn't change anything on me in those years.

I had the flywheel resurfaced the day I put the car back together, ummm

Any more details wanted?

 

Twitch

I was just wondering if the axles are the same for the wuto as the manual.

Does the noise match engine rpm or vehical speed?

  • Author

Nope.

It goes away once the clutch is let out completely or its completely disengaged.

But with the clutch completely engaged the clutch pedal vibrates more as I go

faster.

I thought that was something I need to just get used to...

 

Twitch

You feel it in the clutch pedal with the clutch engaged?

 

You have no clutch freeplay, check the adjustments at the pedals atc.

 

nipper

  • Author

No, no, different thing.

The clutch pedal vibrates whether or not the drivetrain does.

And the drivetrain only vibrates when starting the car, or starting off in 1st.

 

Twitch

You have a few issues here. the clutch pedal vibrating at all timesmeans that there is some force being transmitted thorough the clutch mechanisim to the clutch pedal. The fact that it is a vibration tells me that

a- something is not mounted properly in the clutch. Something is pushing up from the pressure plate, up through the fork, through the linkage, to the pedal.

b- there is no clutch freeplay

  • Author
You have a few issues here. the clutch pedal vibrating at all timesmeans that there is some force being transmitted thorough the clutch mechanisim to the clutch pedal. The fact that it is a vibration tells me that

a- something is not mounted properly in the clutch. Something is pushing up from the pressure plate, up through the fork, through the linkage, to the pedal.

b- there is no clutch freeplay

 

Yeah, I'm pretty sure I didn't leave any freeplay in the pedal.

I might need to put in some freeplay back in the pedal.

But the shuddering is still there when any major force is being applied to the

engine or the engine is starting to apply any force. :-\

 

Twitch

There should always be pedal freeplay

 

Now that vibration....

 

are you sure its not engine related?

Did you put the torque arm back on? Is it in good shape? Do you have all four nuts in place on the trans mount, especially the up-travel stopper with the rubber coated washer?

If you had trouble getting the gearbox into place you may have bent the clutch plate.

 

If the gearbox isn't flush(something between it and the engine, bracket etc for example), it could shudder. Are the two faces tight?

 

Did you position the driveshaft hanger correctly? Sometimes they need a little preload forward or aft to stop shudder.

 

Could first gear have a tooth missing? If you accelerate hard, are their any noises from the box? Any "surging" sensations?

If you had trouble getting the gearbox into place you may have bent the clutch plate.

 

If the gearbox isn't flush(something between it and the engine, bracket etc for example), it could shudder. Are the two faces tight?

 

 

im going with those two (thats where i was heading)

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in

Sign In Now

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.