what fel pro part number? Id be curious what they supply for the uncommon Phase II EJ22
If you bought the car recently like this then you have to wonder how badly it was abused prior. Roll dice, assess things...
If you’ve owned and driven it a long time trouble free before this then it was probably a glitch during install.
1. Resurface the heads yourself and clean them. It’s so easy, compared to DIY head gasket replacement it’s a drop in the bucket.
”testing them” is a complete waste of time on Subaru’s. They always test fine but you’ll see high and low spots every time if you watch during resurfacing. I don’t want high and low spots on a engine that has head gasket issues from a new factory clean seal job
2. Calibrate or somehow verify your torque wrench and your torque procedures. Ignore Fel Pro recommendations and clean and reuse your original Subaru head bolts if you have them. Use Subaru torque procedure and bolts, even the used ones
3. clean the block - do not use sand paper or wire wheel.
4. clean and lubricate the bolt holes and bolt threads so proper torque leads to design clamping loads.
On EJ25s the gasket installed today is not what was originally installed. I favor Subaru, many others do as well, but Fel Pro is used extensively by some shops and I’ve installed a couple without issues. But totally ignore their asinine head bolt comments.
Those are EJ25 part numbers, he’s got an EJ22.