How's the off-road performance of the Scorpion AT Plus? I saw them on 4wheelonline while looking for new tires online. I like them because their tread design is not too aggressive.
I was in the same situation last year. For peace of mind, I ended up getting a set of ironman tires for my Outback. They are not pricey, and their road performance is just fine.
I got a set of Conti DWS06 from 4wheelonline. Dry traction is great, and they feel planted on the road. Performance in the rain and slush is quite impressive also.